Mother Earth

CD by Within Temptationcd cover

Price £7.99

Review by Red Fox

Dutch exports Within Temptation originally started life as a gothic rock group, but with their second full-length release Mother Earth the band changed track dramatically. Here they have introduced a mellower, more symphonic style to their music and placed greater emphasis on the talents of vocalist/ front-woman Sharon den Adel. The result is a rock album incorporating classical vocals (reminiscent of Kate Bush) underlain with orchestral, Celtic and folk sensibilities.

The central theme of the album is mankind’s relationship with nature, in which nature is portrayed in various guises: beautiful, sinister, caring and (most importantly) incontrovertible. To my knowledge, the band has never professed itself to have druid affiliations although the lyrics of many of the tracks here certainly entertain this possibility… which is fortunate for me as it provides the opportunity to review a rock album for TDN!

The album kicks off with the title track: a powerful Celtic affair which I ardently believe should have been notarized as a druid anthem long ago. With unapologetic lyrics such as the chorus line ‘she rules until the end of time/ she goes her own way’ and melodies straight out of Medieval ages (there are even chanting monks towards the end), you can’t help but be impressed by the overall delivery of the track. One of those rare songs that pierce your consciousness and burn a legacy on your skull.

The next track is the brilliant breakthrough single Ice Queen, a guitar-driven rock song about the onslaught of winter. Once again this track falls into the ‘anthemic’ category and is punctuated with an almost metal baseline, making you want to punch the air in accord shouting ‘we’re druid and we kick ass!’ There’ll be no dancing sweetly round the maypole on this occasion.

Although largely up-tempo, the album does have its more gentle moments such as with the spine-tingling ballad Our Farewell. This one has a very simple sound, den Adel singing like an angel over melancholic piano melodies, and does tug on the heartstrings of even tough guys like me. On an album of epic sounding rock songs this beautifully understated track fares surprisingly well.

For those who like a more dramatic sound there are a few seven-minute-plus tracks including an atmospheric masterpiece called The Promise. This tale of murder and vowed revenge sounds something like a miniature movie score, making full-blown use of symphonic elements: think Wuthering Heights crossed with a Hans Zimmer composition. Although the theme of this track harkens back to the darker origins of the band, it is musically a large step forward and one of the reasons the band was later cast- albeit dubiously- in the ‘symphonic metal’ genre.

So there you have it: a perfect example of druidesque music that can seriously rock. The band deals with the nature theme bravely and, it has to be said, very successfully (although not every track is nature-orientated). The quality of the music is consistently high but the components of the songs varied enough to keep things interesting throughout. There’s plenty to explore on this album and I’d recommend in a heartbeat to anyone remotely interested in this genre. Druid music just got exciting.

Available from Amazon.co.uk

Return to CD reviews